August 13, 2026
Under Edina's earlier tree ordinance, a project on a wooded residential lot faced a $95,000 escrow requirement before construction could proceed, as reported by the Star Tribune. The money would be held until the replacement trees were shown to have survived.
Edina rewrote the ordinance in February of this year, and the lawsuit challenging the earlier rule was later dropped.
Edina's Tree Protection Ordinance dates back roughly a decade, but the version that caused the trouble took effect in 2023. It expanded the requirement citywide and applied to any project needing a building permit. If your plans called for removing a protected tree, defined as at least 5 inches in diameter for deciduous species or 15 feet tall for conifers, you had to submit a tree protection plan and post a cash escrow or letter of credit equal to 110 percent of the calculated replacement cost, according to the city's own ordinance page. The city could keep that money if replacement trees didn't survive.
City officials weren't wrong about the problem they were trying to solve. Edina City Manager Scott Neal said the ordinance grew out of years of resident concern that redevelopment was stripping the community's mature tree cover. Between January 2023 and late 2024, the city reviewed 455 permits under the rule, and 68 of those required an escrow. By the city's own count, roughly 3,677 trees were preserved through the process and 755 were removed.
The math worked fine for a routine remodel with one tree in the way. It worked very differently for a family building new on a heavily wooded lot, where dozens of mature trees might need to come down to make room for a foundation, a driveway, and a septic field.
By the fall of 2024, Housing First Minnesota, a trade association representing more than 900 builders, remodelers, subcontractors, and suppliers across the state, sent Edina's city leaders a demand letter asking them to change the ordinance. Nick Erickson, the group's senior director of housing policy, said he had never seen tree replacement figures as steep as the ones circulating in Edina. Neal agreed to meet with the group but stopped short of promising anything.
The conversation didn't resolve it. On August 22, 2025, Housing First Minnesota filed suit against the city in Hennepin County District Court, arguing Edina had no statutory authority to impose the fee structure. The complaint alleged the city had collected nearly $1 million in tree replacement fees over roughly three years, money the ordinance never required the city to actually spend on replanting.
The rule you might have read about no longer exists in its original form.
On February 17, 2026, the Edina City Council voted 4-1 to approve the first reading of a rewritten ordinance, described by city staff as making technical, legal, and operational improvements rather than a wholesale reversal. Parks and Recreation Director Perry Vetter walked the council through the mechanics, and a few changes stand out for anyone budgeting a project:
Not everyone on the council thought the fix went far enough. Councilmember James Pierce cast the lone dissenting vote, saying grouping remodeling projects together with new construction under one set of rules "feels like it disadvantages others in the community." Housing First Minnesota apparently felt differently. By March 13, 2026, the group had dropped its lawsuit once the city had repealed and replaced the ordinance the suit was challenging.
| Before the rewrite | After Ordinance 2026-04 | |
|---|---|---|
| Second escrow release | 3 years after certificate of occupancy | 12 months after certificate of occupancy |
| Offsite replanting | Not permitted | Allowed on a neighboring or approved nearby site |
| Total collected under the old rule | Nearly $1 million over roughly 3 years, per Housing First Minnesota's complaint | Ordinance repealed and replaced |
The number that made headlines, the near-six-figure escrow, described a project on a heavily wooded lot under a rule that no longer applies as written. That doesn't mean the exposure disappeared. It means the shape of it changed, and the details now matter more than the headline did.
If your plan is a kitchen remodel or a modest addition on a lot with a tree or two near the footprint, you're likely looking at a manageable escrow and a shorter wait to get most of it back. If your plan involves a wooded or heavily treed lot where a meaningful number of mature trees have to come down to make room for a new build, budget for the deposit before you write an offer, not after your builder pulls the permit. Ask what a certified arborist or tree supplier would quote for replacement trees on that specific site, then run both the 110 percent method and the per-inch calculation to see which lands lower.
The timing lines up with something else happening in Edina at the same time. According to Better Together Edina, the Heritage Preservation Commission separately updated the Country Club District's Plan of Treatment, adding a new escrow requirement for Heritage Landmark properties effective January 1, 2026, just weeks before the tree ordinance rewrite passed. Two different city commissions, working on two different rules, both landed on financial escrow as the enforcement tool of choice within the same few months.
Does this apply if I'm only doing a kitchen or bathroom remodel? The ordinance applies to any project that needs a building permit, but the escrow only triggers if the project requires removing a protected tree, one at least 5 inches in diameter for deciduous species or 15 feet tall for conifers. An interior remodel with no tree removal typically won't trigger it at all.
What if the lot I'm considering has no mature trees left? The tree protection plan requirement applies when plans call for removing a protected tree; with no mature trees left, there's little or nothing to escrow against, since the deposit is tied to the value of trees actually being removed.
Rules like these rarely make it into a listing sheet, and they can reshape a construction budget by tens of thousands of dollars depending on which side of the line your project falls on. If you're weighing a wooded Edina lot, a teardown, or an addition that reaches toward the tree line, Aaron Spiteri can walk the site with you, help you get ahead of what the city will actually require, and make sure the number in your offer reflects the number you'll really need at closing.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Real estate has never been more competitive and in a market where every dollar matters, so does the professional you choose to represent you. You deserve more than an agent. You deserve a trusted and experienced advisor, a dedicated advocate, someone who understands the market, anticipates opportunities, and protects your interests at every stage of the process. My commitment is simple: to negotiate strategically, guide you with confidence, and fight tirelessly for every last dollar on your behalf. Whether buying or selling, I am committed to delivering an exceptional experience and the strongest possible result. Proudly ranked the #1 solo agent at Lakes Sotheby’s International Realty for total sales volume in 2025.